HPS masthead
What's New?
. June Journal
. Nominations for National Student Science Awards
. Thomadsen Chair of ACMUI
. New Member Welcome Packet
. Homeland Security News
. May Newsletter
. Maher Appointed to NAS Committee
. NRC Comment Period on Rulemaking
. Affiliate of American Institute of Physics
. Online Registration for Annual Meeting
. Radiation Research Society Meeting
Upcoming Events
. NRC Meeting Webcasts - Live
Ongoing
. IRPA Regional Congress
15-19 April 2013
Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
. 50th Annual SRP Conference
Radiation Protection - Spectres from the Past, Visions of the Future
21-23 May 2013
HIC Harrogate, UK
. Canadian Radiation Protection Association (CRPA) Annual Conference
26-30 May 2013
Sherbrooke, Quebec, Canada
. 58th Annual HPS Meeting
7-11 July 2013
Madison, WI
. RITN Workshop
Mitigation and Treatment of Radiation Damage
31 Jul - 2 Aug 2012
Baltimore MD
. Radiation Research Society Meeting
15-19 Sept 2013
New Orleans, LA
. 2013 International Radon Symposium
22-25 Sept 2013
Springfield, IL
20 May 2013

Answer to Question #6833 Submitted to "Ask the Experts"

Category: Radiation Basics

The following question was answered by an expert in the appropriate field:

Q
What form of radioactive thallium would have been used for poisoning such as in the case of Nikolai Khokhlov? Would it have been thallium-200? Or something else? I have looked all over the Internet and cannot find the answer. Because the effects were so dramatic I thought it couldn't have been thallium-201, but I am not really sure. Also, if you do know, would you also be able to tell me if it emits alpha, beta, or gamma radiation? I assume alpha or beta but again can't find a true answer.

A

So far as I am aware, following the poisoning of Khokhlov, there was never a positive identification, or at least a public disclosure, of a particular isotope of thallium as the culprit. In fact, many of the symptoms that Khokhlov suffered were consistent with stable thallium poisoning. These included abdominal pain and vomiting, hair loss (in clumps), eye problems, and some mouth and skin rashes and lesions. From what I understand, some additional symptoms that included degradation in the blood-forming system and the immune system led some American consultants to promote the idea that radioactive thallium was likely responsible.

If that were true, the most likely candidate, in my opinion, would have been 204Tl, a species that can be produced readily by neutron activation of stable thallium in a nuclear reactor. Russia's first nuclear reactor was built in 1954, so the technology was presumably available to prepare this isotope in 1957 when Khokhlov was poisoned. Thallium-204 is a pure beta emitter (maximum energy of 0.76 MeV) with a 3.8-year physical half-life. It is possible that stable thallium was treated in a neutron field to produce 204Tl, although almost all the mass of the thallium present after neutron irradiation would still have been stable, with relatively few atoms having been converted to the radioisotope.

You can find a large number of Web pages that discuss aspects of the Khokhlov case by typing "Khokhlov thallium poisoning" into any of the common search engines. Here are some links to a few representative ones. The first one includes a picture of Kohkhlov prior to his poisoning.


Sorry I can't be completely definitive in answering your question.

George Chabot, PhD, CHP

Answer posted on 26 September 2007. The information and material posted on this website is intended as general reference information only. Specific facts and circumstances may alter the concepts and applications of materials and information described herein. The information provided is not a substitute for professional advice and should not be relied upon in the absence of such professional advice specific to whatever facts and circumstances are presented in any given situation. Answers are correct at the time they are posted on the Website. Be advised that over time, some requirements could change, new data could be made available, or Internet links could change. For answers that have been posted for several months or longer, please check the current status of the posted information prior to using the responses for specific applications.
image
imageimage
Home Chapters Sections Affiliates Ask the Experts Employment Meetings The Lighter Side